The situation
Agencies pitch marketing teams constantly: performance, creative, influencer, retail media, lead generation. Each pitch is a different deck with a different fee model — retainers, percentages of spend, success fees. The CMO cannot compare them, so the decision often goes to the agency with the best presentation, not the best offer.
With a gate
The marketing team's brief states the channels in scope, the current agency setup, the budget band and what it wants: an account team in the company's own language, category experience, a short notice period. The pre-screen rules out what the team never buys: lead-generation agencies, notice periods over six months, no e-commerce work at all. Those agencies stop before a meeting is booked, free of charge and with a reason.
The agencies that pass pitch the agent with their own deck. It asks every agency the same questions about team, fees and notice periods. Every report shows the fee model in the same structure, so a retainer plus percentage can be set against a flat fee. The side-by-side view lines up all agencies that pitched this quarter.
What changes
The team meets two agencies instead of eight — and can show why those two were chosen. The weekly count of declined offers shows whether a pre-screen rule is too strict.